Okay people, I really need your help. Maybe that's my problem...I may have gotten too much help. Regardless, this is still my plea for MORE help. I have recently been on a home improvement spree. Brian is teaching some classes at the college and that has freed up some money for us do do some things around the house. The plan for this round of classes was to get a new stove (my old one was circa 1070) and some new carpet (old carpet is beyond repair). We already got the stove (which I love) and before we attempt the carpet, I decided we should repaint the main rooms because they have not been painted since we moved in nine years ago.
In case you were interested on the before/after stove pics...


However, this is not the problem. I love the stove...no crisis there. The problem is with all the paint. I had originally thought I would just repaint the walls another very neutral color. The goal was just to freshen them up a little. When I started talking about the paint colors, Brian requested that I use some color this time. I am somewhat challenged when it comes to making color choices and making it all blend together, but Brian rarely makes requests, so I thought I would give it a try. I had a group of friends over the Friday before my project began, so with paint samples in hand, I enlisted some help. The general consensus was that I should paint the area above the kitchen cabinets a darker accent color and possibly use the accent color on one wall in the living room just to be fun. We didn't pick out specific colors that day because all I had were versions of tan and we had recently decided that color was the way to go. The next day, I
tackled paint samples at
Wal*Mart by myself. After literally standing in the paint isle for over two hours, I ended up with Butter Nut (yellowy brown) for the living room, Herb Tea (sage green) for the dining room, and Robust Raisin (a dark, brownish purple) for my kitchen/living room accent. The first two were on an idea card that I found...the raisin was just something that I liked...I've always liked sage green and purple together, I don't know why.
I was really excited as I began painting, I thought it was all coming together nicely...but when I was finished (did I mention I did all this in about nine hours??), I wasn't sure that I was crazy about all the color combinations. I have had mixed reviews from the people that have seen it so far. There are a couple that have "loved it" a couple who said they liked it, but I still couldn't tell for sure, and then a couple more who were a little hesitant. When there is hesitation, it seems to be from the purple/
raisiny color that I painted in the entry way. It's funny because the people who aren't crazy about it there seem to like it in the kitchen. I can't decide if it is because you can see all three colors from the living room, the purple is just too dark for the area where you enter the house, or that the purple just interacts with the yellowy brown in a weird way, but not the green. OR maybe the whole thing is just great and I don't know it yet...
Here is my debate: Should I...
- repaint the purple entry way with the sage green from the dining room
- repaint the purple entry way with the yellowy brown that matches the rest of the living room?
- buy the third color...a really light yellow that is supposed to compliment the other two and use that to paint to repaint the entry way?
- OR...am I being too hard on myself all together and I should just leave the whole thing the way it is???? HELP
Okay...so here are the before pics...






And the afters...





Just a side note...I don't know why, but the paint colors show up lighter on film than they actually are...so picture everything a hair darker...especially the purple. Let me know what you think...I am definitely open for suggestions...you won't offend me, I'm not so sure that I'm crazy about it myself. :)